Book Reviews
The New Cast List
My Loony Verin Theory
Predictions (NEW!)
WOT Humor
WOT Fan Fiction
The Science of WOT
The True Power
The Nearly Ultimate Survey Results Version 2.0!
Moiraine and Gandalf
The Power Of Women
Setalle Anan
My Twenty Favourite Scenes
Links

|
For many people, The Shadow Rising is the book that hooked them on the Wheel Of Time series. Rising above the more formulaic aspects of the previous three books, TSR introduced a narrative complexity and a palpable sense of history that captured the imagination and humbled the gentle reader. This is where the meat of the series truly begins, where we really are in the thick of it. We've got Rand and the Aiel in Rhuidean, Perrin in the Two Rivers, and Elayne & Nynaeve in Tanchico. We've got secrets and deceptions, action and suspense, surprises and revelations. We've got the history of the Aiel and the making of history in the White Tower. TSR gives Jordan a chance to stretch his abilities, and he makes the most of it.
We start out in Tear, where everybody is still catching their collective breaths from the climax to The Dragon Reborn, but as Rand drives Callandor into the Stone, the plot splinters into three distinct parts. Rand attempts to fulfill his Aiel destiny in the Waste, while Perrin sets off to rescue the Two Rivers from what turns out to be a terrifying amount of Trollocs and Myrddraal. Finally, Elayne and Nynaeve continue to hunt the Black Ajah, travelling to the chaotic mess that was Tanchico. Along the way, much effort is spent developing characters, giving protagonists like Elayne and Mat some needed 'screen time'. As well, Jordan gives us a glimpse into the Aiel's past all the way to the Age of Legends, a two-chapter section that I would stand up next to the highlights of any great literary giant of the last millennium with pride. Every time I read those chapters, I get a marvelous chill down my spine, as if I'm reading the histories of my own people.
I still have some nagging questions that threaten to break my mind in two (like, what exactly was preventing Asmodean from walking into Rhuidean before the end of the book?), but without question, TSR is the book that vaults Jordan into Tolkien's league.
Well, let's begin breaking down The Shadow Rising:
Plotting - Remarkably, Jordan gives all three main plot threads about the same amount of attention. He may have been tempted to skimp a bit on the Tanchico thread (when you think about it, not a lot really happened there, at least when compared to the other two threads), and he wrapped up the Two Rivers thread a little too quickly, but the narrative was always clear and engaging.
Characterization - TSR spends a lot of time building up Elayne and Nynaeve's characters, and of course Perrin gets a third of the book all to himself. :) I liked Elayne's drinking episode, and Perrin's eventual reaction to the tragic news of his family, but the character that really surprised me and grew a third dimension was Min. Here's a girl who wanted very badly to head down to Tear and find the guy she desperately loved, and when the Tower broke, she had her chance to flee. Instead she stuck around, convinced Lara to help her bust Siuan and Leane from the dungeon, and then got Gawyn to help them escape. You'd almost think she was ta'veren!
Pacing - With three plot threads, Jordan had the freedom to switch back and forth to keep events from happening too soon, and the narrative moved along so well that he could throw a subplot or two in the mix without missing a beat.
Best Scene - It has to be the two-chapter section detailing the history of the Aiel through Rand's ancestor's eyes. (I know, that's a pretty long scene. Sue me. :) ) Runner-up: Perrin arriving in the Two Rivers only to discover his family was slaughtered. Jordan did a great job on that scene.
Best Quote - Perrin squeezed his eyes shut for a moment to keep the tears in. Even when he opened them his hand still trembled on the lad's head. "Well, Cousin Jaim, you tell your children about today. You tell your grandchildren, your grandchildren's grandchildren." "I'm not going to have any," Jaim said stoutly. "Girls are horrible. They laugh at you, and they don't like to do anything worth doing, and you never understand what they're saying." "I think one day you'll find out they're the opposite of horrible. Some of it won't change, but that will."
Most Screen Time - Perrin. Elayne, Nynaeve, Thom, Moiraine, Mat, Rand, Min, Egwene, Egeanin, and even Jaichim Carridin all had their points of view represented, but this was Perrin's book more than anyone. What's odd is that Jordan never used anyone else's POV in the Two Rivers. I guess he wanted to keep Faile and Verin mysterious for the time being.
Overall - I like comparing The Shadow Rising to 'The Empire Strikes Back'; situated in the middle of a fantasy/SF series, both were satisfying, complex, and character-driven. TSR has plenty of scenes that tug at the memory years later, and Jordan's still trying to match the quality of this effort. 5 out of 5 angreals.
Return to the main page!
|
Discussion Forums
|